What is a holographic signature, its legality, and how to digitize it

Holographic signatures continue to be relevant in the validation of legal documents, despite the rise of digital solutions. Many individuals and organizations still use traditional handwritten signatures, even when there are more secure, efficient, and traceable electronic alternatives. This coexistence raises questions about the real validity of holographic signatures in the digital age.

This article explains what a holographic signature is, its legal framework in Spain, its common uses, how it is verified in the event of a dispute, and, above all, how it can be digitized securely and with legal validity.

Definition and characteristics of the holographic signature

A holographic signature is a traditional handwritten signature, made freehand by a person on a physical document, usually on paper. It not only identifies the signer, but also expresses their agreement, consent, or ratification of the provisions of the document.

What are the main characteristics of a holographic signature?

A holographic signature is defined by its direct and calligraphic execution, intrinsically linking the identity of the author with the physical medium of the document. Its main characteristics are:

• Handwritten and physical: it is made on a tangible medium.
• Personal and non-transferable: it reflects personal characteristics of the writing. 
• Evidential value: it can be used as evidence in court, provided its authenticity is proven.
• Expression of will: it certifies that the signer has read, understood, and accepted the content of the document.

Is an autograph signature the same as a holographic signature?

Although in everyday language and in various legal contexts both concepts are often used as synonyms to refer to a handwritten signature, each term has technical nuances that distinguish them in the legal sphere:

• Handwritten signature: any signature made by hand by the person concerned.
• Holographic signature: refers more strictly to documents written entirely by hand by the signatory. 

In common practice and in many legal texts, the term "holographic signature" is used colloquially to refer to any handwritten signature on a physical document, even if it has not been written entirely by the signatory.

In short, it is a conscious and personal act of will, expressed in an analog and unique way, which has legal value provided that certain requirements of authenticity and context are met. It remains valid as long as the legal requirements that confer validity on it are met.

Common examples of the use of handwritten signatures

Although digitization is transforming many processes, there are still many scenarios where holographic signatures remain commonplace:

1. Holographic will: This is the most iconic example. According to Article 688 of the Spanish Civil Code, this type of will must be written and signed entirely in the testator's own handwriting, without the intervention of a notary or witnesses. Its validity depends on the document being dated and signed, and there being no evidence of alteration or coercion.
2. Physical contracts: In sectors such as real estate, art, or family law, many contracts are still signed on paper, especially in contexts where the parties distrust digital technology or lack technological means.
3. Handwritten authorizations: For example, school permits, medical authorizations, or informed consents in rural or low-connectivity environments.
4. Internal business documents: Despite the rise of management software, many SMEs still use handwritten signatures on attendance sheets, expense authorizations, or internal forms.
5. Collectibles and autographs: In the non-legal but commercial sphere, the holographic signature of celebrities (actors, artists, athletes) has high symbolic and economic value.

This type of signature is used especially when a physical mark of acceptance is required or when there are no electronic means available or legally authorized to digitally validate consent.

Legal framework governing handwritten signatures

In Spain, holographic signatures are recognized in multiple legal bodies, although their use has been restricted in favor of more secure and auditable electronic means.

Recognition in the Civil Code

Article 1227 of the Spanish Civil Code establishes that contracts are perfected by mere consent, and the signature—whether holographic or not—is proof of that consent. In this sense, a holographic signature is legally valid provided that it can be proven that it was made by the person to whom it is attributed.

Civil Procedure Law (LEC) and evidentiary assessment

The LEC regulates handwriting expert evidence and signature recognition in court. In the event of a dispute over the authenticity of a holographic signature, the judge may order a judicial examination or even appoint a handwriting expert.

When is a handwritten signature mandatory?

Although the regulatory and administrative trend is to favor electronic and advanced digital signatures, there are cases in which a holographic signature is still mandatory or preferred, including: 

• The holographic will, mentioned above, written entirely by hand by the testator.
• Some notarial documents that require a handwritten signature in the presence of a notary.
• Public deeds (although here the signature is made before a notary, it is still holographic in form). In this case, these may be certificates and authorizations that, due to specific sector regulations, have not incorporated electronic signature mechanisms.

Risks and penalties for forgery or misuse

The forgery of a holographic signature is a crime under Article 390 of the Criminal Code. Specifically: 

• Document forgery: including or altering a signature without authorization.
• Fraudulent use of another person's signature: impersonating another person to sign contracts or documents.

The consequences may include prison sentences (from 6 months to 3 years for anyone who falsifies, alters, or misuses another person's signature) and financial penalties. If the document is public or commercial, the legal act may also be declared null and void, with civil liability and financial damages.

Requirements for a holographic signature to be valid

For a holographic signature to have probative and legal value, it must meet four essential requirements:

1. Identification of the signer: It must be possible to link the signature to a specific person, either by ID number or by their full name. An illegible signature or one without context may be invalid.
2. Manifest will: The person must have signed consciously and without coercion. If it is proven that there was pressure, deception, or manipulation, the document may be declared null and void.
3. Absence of coercion or fundamental error: The signatory must understand the content and consequences of the document. If they sign without reading or understanding it, they could claim vitiated consent.
4. Applicable legal context: If a type of contract or document requires specific requirements (e.g., notarized form), these must be respected.

These requirements are especially relevant in legal proceedings, where the authenticity and context of the signature are meticulously evaluated. If any of these requirements are missing, the holographic signature may lose its probative value or even invalidate the legal act in question.

The holographic signature as evidence in a trial: "Signature recognition"

When a dispute arises over the authenticity of a holographic signature, the legal process may resort to signature recognition, a concept regulated in Articles 320 et seq. of the Civil Procedure Act.

The procedure usually follows these steps:

1. Filing of the lawsuit: One of the parties alleges that the signature is not theirs.
2. Signature comparison: The judge asks the defendant to sign in their presence so that the signature can be compared with the one on the document in question.
3. Appointment of a handwriting expert: If the comparison is inconclusive, an official expert is appointed to analyze features such as pressure, slant, fluidity, speed, and characteristic strokes.
4. Expert opinion: The expert issues a report that may be accepted or challenged by the parties.
5. Court ruling: The judge evaluates the report and other evidence to determine authenticity. This is why it is a key tool in contractual or liability disputes.

This process is costly, time-consuming, and not always conclusive, especially if the signature is very simple or if there are previous signatures from the same individual that are very different (due to aging, illness, etc.).

Digital signature vs. Holographic signature: Key differences

Digital transformation has introduced new ways of signing. Although they appear similar, the legal and technical differences are significant:

Digital signatures, especially qualified electronic signatures in accordance with Regulation (EU) No. 910/2014 (eIDAS), offer a higher level of security and legality than handwritten signatures. Furthermore, they are valid in all European Union member states, which is not necessarily the case with paper signatures.

This type of signature uses cryptographic algorithms to uniquely link the signed data to the signatory, so that any subsequent alteration is easily detectable. 

When to use one or the other?

 The decision between using a traditional signature or an advanced digital solution should be based on the balance between the legal requirements of the procedure and the desired operational efficiency.

• Holographic signature: 

• In very specific contexts such as holographic wills.
• In environments without access to technology or with low digital literacy.
• Due to personal or cultural preference (although this is changing rapidly).

• Advanced digital/electronic signature:

• In any modern administrative, commercial, or contractual procedure.
• When traceability, speed, and enhanced legal certainty are required.
• To comply with regulations such as eIDAS, GDPR, or LOPD-GDD, which require guarantees in the processing of data and documents.

The global trend is to replace handwritten signatures with digital solutions that offer less risk of fraud, greater efficiency, and a better user experience.

The need to digitize holographic processes

Many organizations still initiate processes with handwritten signed paper documents, but then have to scan them and integrate them into digital document management systems. This hybrid approach presents serious problems:

• Lack of integrity: scanning does not guarantee that the document has not been altered.
• Lack of traceability: it is not known who signed it, when, or under what conditions.
• Legal risk: a scan of a handwritten signature is not a valid electronic signature according to eIDAS.
• Difficulty in auditing multiple versions of a document.

Why does scanning a signature not make it digital?

A digitized hand-signed document does not add integrity, security, or traceability. A scanned PDF:

• Is not an electronic signature.
• Can be altered without leaving a trace.
• Does not link the signature to the signer's identity. 
• Does not comply with eIDAS regulations.

How to digitize a holographic signature securely and validly

Digitizing a handwritten signature does not mean converting a scanned PDF into a "valid digital document." It means reproducing the legal act of signing in an electronic environment with the same or greater legal guarantees.

The process must comply with the standards of the eIDAS Regulation, which distinguishes between three levels of electronic signature:

1. Simple electronic signature: basic, without enhanced guarantees.
2. Advanced electronic signature: linked to the signatory and capable of detecting subsequent alterations.
3. Qualified electronic signature: with a qualified certificate and created with a secure device; legally equivalent to a handwritten signature.

What are the steps to validly digitize a handwritten signature?

In order for the transition from handwritten signatures to the digital environment to retain its full legal validity, it is necessary to follow a technical protocol that safeguards the evidence of consent. The process to follow is:

1. Prior identification of the signer: using an electronic ID card, digital certificate, or supervised video identification.
2. Use of a certified platform: that generates time stamps and guarantees the integrity of the document.
3. Association of the signature with the document data: using cryptographic methods that link the signature to the final content. 
4. Audit log: storing metadata (IP, geolocation, exact date/time, device).
5. Secure and accessible storage of the electronically signed document: on servers that comply with GDPR and LOPD-GDD.

This approach transforms the intention to sign holographically into a legally robust digital act.

 Instant legal electronic signature with Tecalis Sign

A leading solution in the Spanish and European market is Tecalis Sign, an advanced and qualified electronic signature platform that allows you to:

• Sign any electronic document with full legal validity according to eIDAS.
• Integration with business systems (ERP, CRM, HR) to automate signature flows.
• Remote video identification validated by the Spanish Data Protection Agency (AEPD).
• Full traceability: each signature generates an audit report with a qualified time stamp.
• Regulatory compliance: GDPR, LOPD-GDD, eIDAS, eIDAS 2.0.

Combined with Tecalis Identity for identity verification, it reduces the risk of impersonation. Companies in the banking, insurance, legal, and public administration sectors already use these solutions to replace handwritten signature-based processes with 100% digital, secure, and efficient workflows.

Conclusion: The holographic signature in the digital age

Holographic signatures have a legitimate place in the Spanish legal system, especially in documents such as holographic wills. However, their widespread use in contracts, authorizations, or administrative procedures is no longer secure or efficient in the current context.

Today, advanced and qualified electronic signatures not only equal but surpass handwritten signatures in terms of legal validity, security, and user experience.

Furthermore, in the near future, driven by the Digital Europe Strategy 2030, holographic signatures will be relegated to very marginal or symbolic uses. Organizations that anticipate this transition will not only improve their operational efficiency but also reduce legal and fraud risks.

The adoption of platforms such as Tecalis Sign and the use of advanced digital certificates allow organizations to maintain the binding force of agreements, streamline operational cycles, reduce risks, and ensure long-term traceability.

Digitization is not an option: it is a strategic obligation. And doing it right is the key to ensuring that every signature, whether electronic or handwritten, has the legal weight it deserves.

Tags